100 reasons why Madeleine McCann was not abducted


Compiled by 'Truestepper' on Sky Discussions:

"It reminds me of a quote from the FBI:"

"Taken alone, each piece of evidence might be argued, but together, enough pebbles become a block of evidentiary granite."


PHYSICAL / APARTMENT / ENTRY

1. All five markers in a sample found under the tiles, behind the sofa (exactly where Eddie, the EVRD [Cadaver] dog and Keela, the CSI [Human Blood] dog, both indicated), are 100% compatible with Madeleine's DNA profile

2. Fifteen of the markers, in a sample found under the luggage liner of the McCann's Scenic (hired 24 days later), are 100% compatible with Madeleine's DNA profile

3. Shutters were not jemmied or forced, as claimed by the parents

4. No signs of forced entry anywhere in the apartment

5. No physical evidence of anyone having entered or left via the window, including:

6. No Lichen disturbance

7. No Fibres

8. No Finger prints of abductor

9. No footprints on bed

10. Only finger prints on the window are those of Kate



DOGS

11. Eddie, the EVRD (Cadaver) dog, positively alerted to the McCann's wardrobe in 5A

12. Eddie, the EVRD (Cadaver) dog, positively alerted at the back of the sofa in 5A

13. Eddie, the EVRD (Cadaver) dog, positively alerted to the veranda outside the parent?s bedroom

14. Eddie, the EVRD (Cadaver) dog, positively alerted to the flower bed at the back of 5A

15. Eddie, the EVRD (Cadaver) dog, positively alerted to a white sleeveless top belonging to Kate

16. Eddie, the EVRD (Cadaver) dog, positively alerted to checked trousers belonging to Kate

17. Eddie, the EVRD (Cadaver) dog, positively alerted to a child?s red T shirt

18. Eddie, the EVRD (Cadaver) dog, positively alerted to a toy belonging to Madeleine

19. Eddie, the EVRD (Cadaver) dog, positively alerted to the key of the McCann's rental Scenic car

20. Eddie, the EVRD (Cadaver) dog, positively alerted to the passenger's door of the McCann's Renault Scenic

21. Keela, the CSI (Human Blood) dog, positively alerted at the back of the sofa in 5A (exact same spot as alerted to by the EVRD dog)

22. Keela, the CSI (Human Blood) dog, positively alerted to the key of the McCann's hire car

23. Keela, the CSI (Human Blood) dog, positively alerted to the interior of the hire vehicle's boot


TANNER SIGHTING

The only perceived evidence of abduction, being the sighting by Jane Tanner at around 21.15 is riddled with inconsistencies and conflicting testimonies, being the fact that

24. None of the scent tracking Search & Rescue dogs followed that trail, and in fact followed another trail completely

25. Jeremy Wilkins (independent witness) failed to spot the ?abductor?, despite being only yards away, while chatting to Gerry

26. Jeremy Wilkins (independent witness) failed to see Jane Tanner walking by, despite being on the same narrow sidewalk at the same time

27. Gerry himself failed to spot the abductor, despite being only yards away, while chatting to Jeremy

28. Gerry contradicted Jeremy by stating that their chat was on the opposite side of the road from that as described, and drawn on a map, by Mr Wilkins

29. Gerry also contradicted Tanner, by stating that his chat with Jeremy was on the opposite side of the road from that mentioned by Jane

30. Jane failed to spot the open window and shutters and blowing curtains coming from Madeleine's bedroom while walking to her apartment at 21.15

31. Jane failed to spot the open window and shutters and blowing curtains coming from Madeleine?s bedroom while walking from her apartment at 21.20

32. Jane never bumped into Jeremy Wilkins (who had walked back to his apartment after the chat with Gerry) while walking back from her apartment at 21.20

33. Russell O'Brien failed to spot the open window and shutters and blowing curtains coming from Madeleine's bedroom while walking to his apartment at 21.30

34. Matthew Oldfield failed to spot the open window and shutters and blowing curtains coming from Madeleine's bedroom while walking to his apartment, which was right next door, at 21.30

35. Matthew failed to spot the open window and shutters and blowing curtains while checking on Madeleine and the twins

36. Matthew failed to spot the open window and shutters and blowing curtains coming from Madeleine's bedroom while walking from his apartment back to the Tapas at around 21.35

37. Jane failed to spot the open window and shutters and blowing curtains coming from Madeleine's bedroom while walking to her apartment at 21.45

38. Russell failed to spot the open window and shutters and blowing curtains coming from Madeleine's bedroom while walking back from his apartment at 21.50

39. Tanner's description has changed several times

40. It makes no sense, especially if (as the McCann's claim) that this was a well planned abduction, that the abductor walks across the very road used by the parents to check on their children

41... The abductor failed to hear either Tanner, Gerry or Wilkins, and continued on the path that would put him in the full vision of all three

42... If the abductor had lifted Madeleine out of the bed, then he would be carrying with her head to his right hand side, not on the left as in Tanner's claimed sighting


SMITH SIGHTING

43. The Smith family (independent witnesses) sighting has, with the exception of one brief mention two years later, been completely ignored by the McCann's and their private detectives from day one (no e-fit / press conference / media onslaught) despite the fact that?

44. There was huge publicity given to the Tanner sighting, including the pressure put on the Portuguese authorities to get the details out there

45. The Smith family descriptions have never changed

46. The sighting was only minutes before the 'alarm' was raised

47. The sighting was only 250 metres from the apartment

48. This sighting would have explained many of the inconsistencies of the Tanner sighting as mentioned above

49. There were several members of the family who witnessed this man carrying a child

50. The general area and timing of the sighting made by the family can be corroborated by a restaurant receipt for that evening

51. The general description of the man could fit Gerry McCann

52. The description of the child matches Madeleine

53. The type of trousers match those possessed by Gerry

54. Trousers match in terms of colour

55. Trousers even match in terms of the visible buttons as mentioned by one of the family

56. Martin and his wife later identified the carrier, through the distinctive carrying style, as being Gerry McCann


Given much of the above, the remarkable coincidence that?

57. The pressure put on the PJ to highlight the Tanner sighting came at exactly the same time as the Smith family were being brought back to Portugal to go over the sighting in more detail

58. The sighting was in a different part of town from the Tanner sighting

59. It was also heading in a completely different direction

60. The carrying style was completely different to that of the Tanner sighting

61. And yet the McCann's deliberately altered the Smith sighting carrying style so as to match that of the Tanner sighting, during the only ever significant mention of the sighting, in a McCann made reconstruction aired only a few days after Amaral's (in which he included the Smith sighting)

62. They also tried to morph the carrier into the same man as seen by Tanner, despite significant differences in descriptions


BEHAVIOURAL

There are many instances of strange behaviour from the McCann's, not being consistent with parents of a child abducted by paedophiles, including (but not limited to)?

63. Kate complaining about the speed of a police vehicle while being take to look into a new lead at PJ HQ (sighting caught on CCTV)

64. Gerry laughing and joking and sucking lollipops while one of the most significant abduction leads came to a climax

65. Very little mention of the huge award available over the last three years

66. Despite raising millions through their fund, and spending thousands on media monitoring, they continue to charge for travel kits and for printing off posters designed to help find their daughter

67. Lack of physical searching during the first few days

68. Lack of physically handing out leaflets / putting up posters themselves

69. Hiring cowboy private detectives with no expertise or experience in finding children

70. Gerry smirking when asked by a Sky News presenter how he feels when someone comes forward who is certain that they have seen Madeleine

71. When up to 14 possible sightings of Madeleine emerged in Malta, resulting in a huge police operation including Interpol, the McCann's hot footed it to Germany for more TV plugs

72. When the most promising sighting of all was made in Belgium, a 110% certain sighting by a child therapist, considered so credible by authorities that they despatched a forensics team, the McCanns went looking in Huelva, Spain

73. Gerry's initial claim, as overheard by another holidaymaker, within minutes of the alarm being raised, that Madeleine had been taken by paedophiles. How did he know that?

74. Gerry caught on Camera laughing his head off only a few days after his daughter had been abducted by paedophiles as claimed by the parents

75. Despite refuting the claims of the dogs / Scenic findings, the McCann's continued to submit ridiculous reasoning for them, including Sea bass, sweat, dirty nappies, rubbish en-route to dump, rotten meat, and attending to 6 bodies before the holiday, amongst others

76. Kate refusing to answer 48 police questions

77. The McCann's and their holiday friends all refusing to attend a police reconstruction

78. Despite the Madeleine's disappearance looking like an inside job from the outset, the McCann's and their friends were happy enough returning their children to the MW creche just hours later, despite not knowing if any of the staff were involved

79. When Kate raised the alarm, she ran back to the table, leaving the twins in the apartment while not knowing whether the abductor(s) were still onsite

80. Kate shouting They've taken her!?, not distinguishing between Madeleine and her sister Amelie


STATEMENT INCONSISTENCIES

90. When describing Madeleine sleeping that night, Kate said she was under the covers where as Gerry mentioned that his daughter slept without the covers, as was normal

91. Matthew Oldfield initially claimed that Kate and the children were at the tennis courts when he arrived there at 18.30 where as the rest of the Tapas 9 claim otherwise

92. David Payne's 18.30 / 18.40 check on Kate (last person out with the parents to see Madeleine) : According to Kate the sliding door was closed, and that David didn't actually enter the apartment, remaining at the door. But according to David, the door was open and he definitely entered the apartment.

93. Matt Oldfield chivvying up the Payne's at 21.00 : Matt claims he passed them near the top of the road, but David claims to have passed him by the swimming pool, Fiona claims to have passed him outside 5A, and Dianne Webster initially claimed that Matthew wasn't even there.

94. Prior to the PJ arriving at 12:40/12:50 Russell O'Brien has written the timeline for them all, including, Jane tanner sees stranger walking carrying child. He does this while Gerry McCann sits at the same table. However, according to Jane Tanner it's three o' clock in the morning when she informs Gerry McCann for the first time


OTHER

95. Various other possible withheld evidence as hinted at, including intercepted phone calls / text messages

96. Independent witness statement (from McCann neighbour) regarding the luggage door of the McCann's hire vehicle being open morning, noon and night

97. Gerry's missing hold-all / tennis / kit bag which he was seen with the day Madeleine disappeared cannot be located by detectives

98. Gaspar (UK GPs) statements detailing concerns about the father and one of his friends on holiday with them

99. Yvonne Martin (Social Worker) statement regarding concerns about the same friend

100. This same friend calls the Metropolitan Police Crime Specialist Director (a number which is also used as the out of hours contact for the Met's Child Abuse Investigation Team) 24 hours after the alarm

109 comments:

Anonymous said...

As the sun rose over Praia da Luz on the morning of May 3rd 2007, the day Kate McCann was later to run from her holiday apartment screaming, "They've taken her, they've taken her," Madeleine McCann was already dead.

And both parents knew.

Because they had killed her.

Mrs F Mason
Lancashire
England

Anonymous said...

i totaly agree with the first post.
and i do believe the media know this too and are waiting to strike
and i dont think we will have to wait much longer

Anonymous said...

I agree with first post also.The McCanns believe they have gotten away with murder, but they will get caught in the end.Lets all hope it will be soon.

Anonymous said...

61. And yet the McCann's deliberately altered the Smith sighting carrying style so as to match that of the Tanner sighting, during the only ever significant mention of the sighting, in a McCann made reconstruction aired only a few days after Amaral's (in which he included the Smith sighting)

Evidence that can not be argued.
How I wish a journalist would ask the McCanns the simple question
why they altered the Smiths sighting in their reconstruction.
Poor Madeleine, parents that play games with a faked abductor.

Melanie Vogel said...

I do totally agree with the post, the behaviour is extremely strange nobody would leave their children in the appartment after having found that the daughter is missing or let the twins attend a crèche it's so obvious. So surprised they' got away with it for so long. Please McCann's give up, poor, poor Maddie!

Anonymous said...

The day the police searched for the corpse in Murat's garden was the day the McCanns went to Huelva, Spain.
I expected them to wait for the results of the excavations, right in front of Murat's house, and all day long.They knew she was not there.

Anonymous said...

i hope someone puts this on youtube

tony. said...

HOW ACCURATE ARE LIE DETECTOR TESTS? GIVE THEM BOTH ONE AND QUESTION THEM ABOUT THAT POOR LITTLE GIRL. I DARE BET THEY WOULD FAIL IT,PAIR OF EVIL LIARS 99.9% OF PUBLIC MUST FEEL THE SAME WAY TOO. :-(

Anonymous said...

I do, to some degree, agree with these comments. But, watching CrimeWatch this evening and seeing the pain behind the father's eyes, it's hard to tell what has actually happened. What kind of parent would leave their child, in an apartment, while they go so far away? Then, to know once they've realised their daughter has gone missing, STILL leave there twins? It doesn't make sense, at all. I just hope Madeline gets her justice, on whatever it is, that has happened to her. If she has died, (and her parents are the reason) I sure as hell hope that the other children get taken off of them. They won't be able to keep secrets for much longer, lie detector tests are 98% accurate, all that is left is to keep the search going, and do that important test.

Anonymous said...

Don't know what to think but if Jeremy Kyle gets to the truth every morning, why can't the police with a lie detector!!!?

Anonymous said...

I think its all very odd. Do u no how u wud react if this happened to you. I dont agree for one minute that they left the children its rong on so many levels. But after watching crime watch and seeing the speak and the pain they feel. I just don't think they would do it the lil girl was conceived through ivf so she was/is a very much wanted little girl. I think kate went into panick mode and didn't no what to do hence y she left the twins. No one can say how u wud react. And as for all the dna of course it would b all over the apartment!

Anonymous said...

Totally agree, Let Jeremy Kyle at them and do that lie detector test!!! When on holiday I would never leave children like that to go out for a meal with friends!!! Poor Maddie; such a beautiful little girl. What reason could there be for a parent to dispose of a child when so many childless couples would give anything to have one. I am sure we all want this to come to an end - we all need to know what happened and then one way or another little Maddie can be at peace.

Anonymous said...

I agree with the above comment that why hasn't a lie detector test been done

Anonymous said...

Stop with the demands for the use of lie detectors folks. They're claimed to be between 60 and 95% accurate but the tests can be passed easily with some basic coaching (short version: stress yourself out during the control period of questioning). Their use is not admissible as evidence in UK courts due to this factor and the questions over their inaccuracy. And stop watching Jeremy Kyle while you're at it, he's an odious man. http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/magazine-22467640

Anonymous said...

There are ways that can help to find truthful information ....Hypnotize both parents and Lie detectors may bring forth crucial answers!!! can't believe this has not been carried out under the circumstances !!

Anonymous said...

The truth is out there....it's finding it thats the problem. ...the thought of what that poor sweet child went through. ..makes me feel positively sick I hope with all my heart she is found and my thoughts got out to 'Ben's' mum also...it's been even longer for her

Anonymous said...

On a far less constructive note, Maddie is an anagram of im dead.

Anonymous said...

It states the fact , " no false entry was found " so look between the lines

Anonymous said...

The MacCann's refused a lie detector test from the start!!

ggilbert903 said...

why refuse a lie test if your innocent .refusing the test answers the question

Anonymous said...

Uk courts do not use lie detector tests as they are not 100% accurate and therefore the finding can be inconclusive. In all honesty this girl was never abducted, her parents have either murdered her or there has been an accident and they have covered it up. Either way i dont know how they can live with themselves. They do not deserve to have custody of their other children.

I hope they get whats coming to them i really do.

Anonymous said...

what surprised me was the fact that maddie asked where her parents were the night before when she and her brother woke up crying, knowing that ,they shouldn't have then left the kids another night. what possessed them to leave the kids in the first place and they did it every night..i cannot believe that they thought it was ok to leave kids on there own any one else would have been prosecuted but not hem as he Is a high profile man as a doctor.the mother doesn't look like a person who has lost a child I think she has some sort of depression and she has accidently killed maddie. how she can say they did nothing wrong is beyond me and they shouldn't have any kids with them. if they were conceived through ivf then what the hell are they playing at maybe she couldn't have kids but then didn't want them. its all such a sad event but I still think the parents are to blame for this and I hope that they soon find the culprits who ever they are and that they are punished.

Anonymous said...

You lot should all be police officers. You obviously know exactly what happened.

Anonymous said...

Is it me or does the e.fit match photos of Gerry??

Anonymous said...

You just know the kind of people commenting on here know f#c all when they say 'let Jeremy Kyle at them, he always gets the truth' ha ha ha ha mindless idiots. But worryingly characteristic of a weird and disturbing shift in societal understanding of what argument, evidence, truth and reality actually is....

Anonymous said...

shame on you all. You nasty evil mouthed people. Leave it to the police and hopefully the truth will come out. Now all crawl back under your stones

Anonymous said...

Never knew you could get so many idiots in the one place.

Anonymous said...

Further to my comment at 17.21 I've read a few more comments one even mentions using hypnosis and a lie detector - fuck me are these people for real? If any of the drivel being peddled were true why haven't the Met reached the same conclusion? Which is what one does after the evidence has been presented, it's called argument (and not the kind on Jeremy Kyle).

Anonymous said...

A big cover up it was probably something that went wrong and the facts are hidden .High profile people love glory ,

jkh said...

Here's some more interesting reading: This is the link to the Complete Mystery of Madeleine McCann forum where there is a wealth of research http://jillhavern.forumotion.net/ and then there is Goncalo Amaral's book which has been translated into English: goncaloamaraltruthofthelie.blogspot.co.uk/
Thank you for visiting the blog.

Ray said...

They're Doctors. This keeps them above suspicion. Harold Shipman was also a Doctor!

They sedated her (and the others) to keep them asleep whilst they ate at a Tapas bar. Maddie was over-sedated, with disastrous consequences.
Gerry and Kate knew that they would go to jail. They covered it all up out of love for their other children.

The truth will out

Anonymous said...

@18.55 where is the evidence that she was sedated, how could you possibly know her body has never been found... Deal in facts not conjecture and you may, just may have a small amount of credibility..,

Anonymous said...

Uk courts do not use lie detector tests as they are not 100% accurate and therefore the finding can be inconclusive. In all honesty this girl was never abducted, her parents have either murdered her or there has been an accident and they have covered it up. Either way i dont know how they can live with themselves. They do not deserve to have custody of their other children.

I hope they get whats coming to them i really do.

Anonymous said...

The McCann have guilt all over their face!!!

Anonymous said...

We believe what we want, we dont know what really happened, no photos, no statements, as for behaviour how many of u have had your kids taken, y wouldn't a mother run out and shout that her babys gone, u wouldn't think in a normal way, as for the window thing, ive read it was open, unless u were there no one can say for sure, shes dead or her mum and dad killed her. Its nice to see that so many people think the worse, I hope to god she has been looked after and is okay, and that one day shes home with her family.

Anonymous said...

It's all a cover up. I think last nights crime watch was completely staged. Why after 6 years are the public coming forward. Come on we are not stupid. I think their time is up now and last nights airing is all to do with reaction on their part. They have courted so much publicity thus far and they have to keep it up. That's why they both look do drained. Wouldn't you. Their time is up.

Anonymous said...

If they are guilty, why did they insist on further investigations when they have already gotten away with it?

Anonymous said...

I do not know the facts along with the rest of the people on here, but if they are guilty I'm amazed that this has not been established long before now. The sad fact is that society is turning us all into such sneering cynics!

jkh said...

To catch up with the latest news on the McCann case please see here: http://jillhavern.forumotion.net/

Anonymous said...

Because they made lots of money since with their fund raising... bet they've never done a days work since. I've always said it from day one, call it a sixth sense... but i've never been wrong.

Anonymous said...

I think that they had given her a sedative to ensure she slept but accidentally overdosed her.
Then Gerry either threw her body in the sea or in a building site hole.
So very sad that they will not admit the truth!
If it was my child that had been abducted i would think of them every day not just at family gatherings!

Graham Sweet said...

i you've telled the story so many times over years you start to believe it yourself, actors do this all the time. so for me personally a lie detector test wouldn't work.
i can only think of one thing that would probably work and thats banned now, Waterboarding!
and i do believe that one of them if not both did it themselves and dumped her in the sea!
and in the meantime poor maddie can't rest.

Anonymous said...

I think you have hit the nail on the head.

Anonymous said...

I for one dont beleive th McCanns had anythng to do wth their daughters disapearance, How does anyone knw how they would act under those circumstances,? And of course there were inconsistancies! There always is in these cases when every man and hs dog are speculating wth few actual facts. I seem to remember a case sum time ago where a couple were charged wth th murder of their baby daughter because no one could beleive that a dingo could sneak into a crowded campsite, step over a sleeping child and carry th baby off. The parents were seen to be acting strangely, and public scrutenty villified two totally innocent people. As was discoverd when two men found th babies torn and bloodied bodysuit in an abandoned dingo den, DNA taken determined that it was a dingo that killed her, and only after this did many stories come out about dingos attacking small children and on some occasions tried to drag them away! My point being, lets go by the facts, has anyone thought that while th McCanns r being blamed for Maddies disappearance, the real abductoswis walking free, able to do ths horrendous act again.!

Anonymous said...

How do you account for the fact that two British sniffer dogs, Eddie and Keela, both alerted to blood and death scent in the same places? Those places included Kate McCann's clothes, Maddie's cuddlecat toy, behind the sofa in the McCann's apartment, in the wardrobe of the McCann's apartment, and in the car that the McCann's hired 25 days after Maddie went missing? Then we have Mr Smith who identified Gerry McCann as the man who was walking towards the beach/Church with a child. This sighting is believed to be of McCann carrying his dead daughter somewhere for disposal before moving her again to her final resting place.

Are the McCann's really innocent? The facts point towards them being involved in Maddie's disappearance, having concealed her body and staged a fake abduction, which makes their Fund fraudulent. That is the conclusion of the Portuguese police before they released their official files into the public domain. Have you read those files? They are on the internet, freely availablehttp://themaddiecasefiles.com/

Anonymous said...

They gave her sleeping tablets before she went to bed so that she did not wake up crying like she did the night before. She then died in her sleep with overdose and they covered it up... thats what I think..

Anonymous said...

Well ur here !!!!

Anonymous said...

For all those that believe Madeline's parents didn't have a hand in her demise - get real. The only reason the MET haven't done anything is all evidence so far is too circumstantial. Get a psychic involved to find the body, then lock them both up for life.

Anonymous said...

There is no such thing as a lie detector. There is a polygraph, commonly called a lie detector by the ignorant.

Anonymous said...

Another thing not mentioned in this, as a mother I always found it strange that Kate had washed Madeleine's "Cuddle Cat" her favourite toy, in the days after her "abduction." Now if this was my daughter missing, I wouldn't have washed anything belonging to her to this day, it would have destroyed any remaining smell and reminders of her.

Anonymous said...

she was crying for awhile the night before according to the neighbours so im guessing they did sedate her but its only a guess we have no idea what happened and i dont believe we ever will

Anonymous said...

We all know the full name!! And it is often refered to as a lie detector by profesionals and civilians alike, arrogant t***

Anonymous said...

You are right the children should never have been left at home if this was a normal working class couple who left their children unattended on numerous occasions in a foreign country they would have been arrested for neglect and social services would have taken the other children out their care. No parent in their right mind leaves their child unattended.

Anonymous said...

And agree a lie detector should be done, more could be done, would be interested in hearing a good psychics opinion and body language expert analysis

Anonymous said...

This never happened.

Anonymous said...

I do not believe Madeleine was abducted.

I believe she died in the apartment whilst alone and unsupervised and that her parents have covered it up.

The Crimewatch reconstruction was a sham.

And the e-fit is a dead ringer for Gerry McCann.

Anonymous said...

I agree a lie detector test is not 100% accurate but also trial by jury (12 people) would not be a forgone conclusion.

Anonymous said...

I completely agree with this post. I mean, the death scents on her cuddle cat - that was washed, he mothers clothes and in a car rented 20 odd days AFTER she disappeared (tell me, if they are innocent, how did this happen?) , the inconsistencies of their FRIENDS statements only to ignore the one true statement of the smiths. They covered it up and after making millions. They're getting away with murder and being paid to do so. It's sickening. I don't care if they don't have enough evidence to lock them up just yet, but their kids should be taken off them till they do. And the money. Scumbags.

Anonymous said...

I thought the same few days ago,I'm guessing they have buried her somewhere

Anonymous said...

totally agree, I`ve said that from day one that they've sedated her and she over dozed

Anonymous said...

I totally agree, I have thought this from day one, they sedated her and she over dozed and they've disposed of the body,

Anonymous said...

Lie detectors, aka polygraphs, are not proven and a significant proportion of the scientific community doubts their validity. From Wikipedia (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polygraph#Validity): Polygraphy has little evidence to support its use.[11][12][13] Despite claims of 90% validity by polygraph advocates,[14] the National Research Council has found no evidence of effectiveness.[12]

Anonymous said...

What a bunch of generally gullible, ignorant and ill informed folks on this site. Your comments simple highlight the very big chips on your shoulders.

Anonymous said...

What they did was not against any law.

Anonymous said...

Yes true. Guilt of leaving her, nothing more. Let the purest.....

Anonymous said...

@19:10 and your credibility twat? anonymous indeed

Anonymous said...

You are a God. Who will win the 3.30 tomorrow...I'll split.

Anonymous said...

I have to agree.. I used to feel dreadfully sorry for them.. but after reading and hearing things that went on it could have been a tragic accident that had to be covered up...in a way I hope it is, far better than dreading what the poor little mite would otherwise be going through...

Anonymous said...

disgusting examples of parents. make that disgusting pair of murder suspects. as mentioned above which parent on earth would wash the favourite toy of a child that had just been abducted - the smell/stains/chewed ears etc of the toy would have become so precious to any normal parent. they hired a car 12 hours later and Madelieines blood was 100% dna matched as being in the boot of the car! whats the point of scientific dna advances if the results are just ignored?? its a complete joke! I just hope little Madeleine didn't suffer too much whilst paying the ultimate price for being born to two disgusting parents through no choice of her own. God rest her little soul x

Anonymous said...

I lived in Australia at the time and totally believed in Lindy Chamberlain's innocence.. and was proven correct. I also firmly believed in the McCann's story... but now after watching Crimewatch, having read about the sniffer dogs, the inconsistencies, their totally self absorbed behaviour whilst on holiday... you know what??? I smell a rat....

Anonymous said...

There is nothing gullible at all people are entitled to there opinion no matter how far-fetched it can be, UK Police hold no jurisdiction in this case and as such have been treating this as a "Missing Person" as that is the most support they can offer when a crime has been committed on foreign soil, The Portuguese closed the case as "Incomplete" and have been dragged through the mud by a v.callous PR team & Legal team set up by the McCann's and that much is believable but the article lists 100 Facts about the case in the public domain which can be obtained with thanks to the Freedom of information act.

I personally believe that Maddie like the twins was prescribed some form of sedative or psycho-stimulant such as "Ritalin" Maddie was described as a hyperactive child and knowing Kate was a GP would probably be comfortable giving her children medication, On this night Kate & Gerry planned on going out for the evening with there friends the "Tapas-9" so I believe Kate gave the twins & Maddie one of the sedatives knowing Maddie does not normally sleep through and that she ran away and hid in the bushes the night or 2 before Kate decided on this occasion to give Maddie slightly more, Once Kate came back to check her child she found she was cold and died.

I believe it was all a tragic accident that got out of hand and is being covered up at the end of the day only one person has suffered in all thi and that's that small innocent lil girl who had to much personality & energy for her mum.

Anonymous said...

sadly... I think that is a possibility :(

Anonymous said...

totally agree, just the smell of her on the toy would give me comfort...

Anonymous said...

Overdozed...Is that the same as over slept? Bozo.

Anonymous said...

http://www.cwporter.com/mccann.htm

Interesting reading definitely guilty

Anonymous said...

They have agreed to take the test on a few occasions (40 times) but never actually took a test.

Anonymous said...

The evidence is that whilst all the noise, fuss and chaos was going on in the hours after Madeline's disappearance, the twins never woke up once. A friend of the Mccans commented on how in unnaturally quiet they were and that Kate kept going over to them, staring at them and feeling for their heartbeats

Anonymous said...

Never let the truth get in the way of a good yarn, hey.

Someone's been watching a little too much CSI methinks...

Anonymous said...

Whatever happened to innocent until proven guilty?

Anonymous said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Anonymous said...

Exactly what i thought when i saw the photo fit on the news

Anonymous said...

thave got gilt riten all over there faces thay will rot in hell

Anonymous said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Anonymous said...

What would be the benefit of the Mc Cann's killing their own daughter ???, I think its terrible that people could think they hurt Madeline themselves...I totally agree they made some very bad decisions when leaving the children alone, especially after as said on T.V..Madeline had asked ''where was u last night'' So knowing that the children had woken the previous night whilst they was out, they still did it again the next night...that alone would have stopped myself from leaving them again, as the guilt of knowing how scared she must have been, would have overthrown the desire to eat out with friends,rather than look after them. But I dont believe, or hope they would intentionally hurt her & yet still have two more children...it just doesn't make sense. If they wanted rid of the kids, then dont people think they'd/anyone would do whatever to all the kids, not just one. What happened was terrible, but hopefully if she's alive lets hope they can find her, but if something else untoward happened then let's hope that is discovered too, and whoever needs to be brought to justice...is. I also agree with Jane Moore who wrote in the paper today...that if after this media frenzy/investigation comes to nothing, then that should be enough....we/they've tried...but she cannot be found and everythings been exhausted. Because there is an element that, why does this story keep getting so much coverage...when there is plenty of missing people,children...that we have never even heard about.

Anonymous said...

Well said @ 19.51. And for the parents out there, you should be ashamed of yourselves.

Anonymous said...

One of them killed her, the other helped to cover it up. My money is her mother & Gerry covered it up to save his wife.
Where did they put her body, surly the hire car must have a tracking device to show where it has travelled to?

Anonymous said...

If the family were being watched by a paedo ring and they would have to be watch to plan an abduction, why take only one child, specifically, when not both girls?

Anonymous said...

You know that eye witness testimonies are notoriously poor, right? Imagine if you were questioned about someone you passed on the street 3 days ago, how much could you say about what they were wearing/etc? It's not like they come with a sign saying "THIS PERSON IS IMPORTANT, REMEMBER THIS!"

Anonymous said...

(And that you're all assuming that the parents, who are statistically the most likely to kidnap/kill their children, were NEVER investigated by the police is very naive.)

Anonymous said...

I think they have sedated her too much and killed her and covered up the murder

Anonymous said...

The law says, parents can be prosecuted if they leave a child unsupervised ‘in a manner likely to cause unnecessary suffering or injury to health’.

I think they did just that actually.

Anonymous said...

As a mother of 4 I would NEVER leave my children in a house/apartment alone to go for dinner!!! And for them to say it was years ago get over it. SHAME ON BOTH OF YOU! I wouldn't be able to live with myself knowing she had been taken through no fault of my own. Then washing her toy? Only thinking of her at family do's there so many things they say and do that just don't add up. To many to even put on here

I agree they sedated the children for the sake of a meal. And they got it wrong this time. It cost poor Maddie her life.

They should have been sharged with child neglect!!! They should be monitored round the clock for the 2 children they have.

I believe there guilty NO DOUBT

jade.l said...

Right so the Mccann's left there children alone, yes they shouldn't have done that but do you really think they thought there was even a possibility of maddie getting abducted? Also the Portuguese police made loads of mistakes during the investigation which is why all forensic evidence could not be used as evidence. The police dogs which were used are likely to make mistakes, the Mccann's had been staying there for days all there DNA would all over that apartment. So there reports don't add up? If your child ever went missing would you be able recollect every detail of that whole day? They would have been terrified and also feeling guilt, plus all other emotions I can't even begin to comprehend. The case was was also closed, if they had been involved in maddies disappearance why would they fight and appeal for the case to be reopened??

Anonymous said...

hang them both they have to blame anyway. who wld go out and leave your kids in this country let alone another. but i do think they have done it

anonymous said...

What sort of parent leaves their kids alone in an apartment in a foreign country?? Certainly not me!! Can I ask your opinions if I go to a neighbours house on the next cul De sac which is 18 meters away for a barbecue and wine would it be Ok to leave my kidsHome alone in bed?

anonymous said...

What sort of parent leaves their kids alone in an apartment in a foreign country?? Certainly not me!! Can I ask your opinions if I go to a neighbours house on the next cul De sac which is 18 meters away for a barbecue and wine would it be Ok to leave my kidsHome alone in bed?

Anonymous said...

Second that

Anonymous said...

No it would never be ok!!! They should of at the very least be in regular touch with social services over the neglect which lead to maddys disapearance! My prayers are with that little girl everyday she is missing along with every other missing child out there (who hasn't had the same media coverage as the mccanns) In all fairness to kate & Gerry they have forgiven themselves for think what if...
what if we hadnt of gone out and left our 3 precious children alone in an unfamilur place with all the doors unlocked while we enjoyed a much needed rest from all those tennis lessons while our children spend all day at kids club..........
U mite aswell stuck a banner outside saying .....beautiful children inside help yourself!!!!!!!! u mite aswell as handed her over if this is what really happened. im sceptical

Anonymous said...

I completely agree that they had something to do with it

Morgan C said...

I agree!

Anonymous said...

that e fit is so like Gerry mc cann poor madeline being left alone in a dark room in strange country kate Gerry should be ashamed and tell truth

Anonymous said...

I think that they shouldn't have left their children alone in an apartment while they went out to get drunk with friends! How irresponsible is that? I think they must have killed her with something like Gerry's golf set because that went missing on the same day as Maddy did? A bit strange...
Have you thought about helping with the enquiry of her dissepearance?

Anonymous said...

I SWEAR DOWN THE NEW EFIT LOOKS EXACTLY LIKE MADDYS DAD!!??? That's really creepy! Who agrees.,?

Sam Macken said...

They are totally guilty, I've said this from day one!!

Anonymous said...

She could have been killed accidently. Here's a scenario. Both parents are meeting up with friends which they were, they put kids to bed, the twins are tired so they are more or less asleep but poor maddie is wide awake, so they can't leave them whilst maddie is awake, so what's to say that they had medicine lying around after all they both work in the medical profession so they could get hold of drugs, they could have given her a shot of tranquilizer and she went to sleep then they went out. But later they return to find maddie with no pulse and she had an allergic reaction to the meds hence being sick on her teddy (which is why Kate washed the teddy to hide the evidence) because if it was found she died due to medical intervention they both knew that they would be sent down and lose their highly paid jobs, they have a lot to lose if the truth came out

Anonymous said...

Why don't you all go an get an education and become one of the countries elite detectives so that you can have an educated and well informed opinion of what may or may not have happened!

Anonymous said...

The thing is if they are not willing to answer questions there is no way they would do a lie detecor test .my worry is they have 2 other children in there care i hope them children are safe from any form of abuse .

Anonymous said...

the mccanns will win as usual put your house on it

Anonymous said...

I think that I am entitled to an opinion as are all others here. Those of you with derogatory comments towards others here only show your own ignorance.
It all comes down to hard evidence that we all know however as a parent I would never leave my children alone ANYWHERE! That is negligence and pure selfishness therefore the police have let them free of any charges for this matter alone. Why would I believe anything else they tell us now? They are guilty of all of the above I wouldn't believe anything else they had to say. As for the Jeremy kyle comments.. haha I dare them to sit on stage with him! They wouldn't last 10 minutes!